If You Must Know
I am often asked: "Why did you convert to Judaism? Glutton for punishment?" It breaks down like this -
Rebellious by nature, I became a real pain-in-the-ass toward the end of my teenage years. Politics (anti-choice) and policies (no female priests) in my parents' Church of Choice rubbed me the wrong way. Then I was asked to sign a petition denouncing The Last Temptation of Christ, a movie best avoided because it sucked not banned because it challenged church doctrine. Freedom of speech and all... So I rebelled. And questioned. And then rebelled some more.
I looked into other Christian denominations. A Jehovah's Witness used to visit me every weekend and I read all her material. Fascinating, but too conservative for my free-loving and, according to her, "doomed" soul. A co-worker turned me on to Latter-Day Saints. I liked The Book of Mormon, good people, but couldn't get behind their hard-core stance against homosexuality and women's rights. Most Protestant faiths left me drained and wanting to never again see the inside of a church.
I figured I was without a home. When I wrote a paper titled "The Historicity of Jesus Christ" for a Humanities class, I learned about the Messianic Principle and early Christians - especially Saul...err...Paul and the ways he broke with Judaism to found a new religion.
Good stuff. I was a hit at parties.
Hippie friends turned me on to Eastern philosophies and faith took another turn. I read the Bhagavad Gita and incorporated other practices into my daily routine: meditation, Tai Chi, natural healing, yoga, vegetarianism, and a desire to graduate Samsara. Still. I'm a monotheist at heart and couldn't get on board with any idol-worshiping. Much love, though.
Then my friend Julie asked me to visit her synagogue. No, she did not recognize a kindred spirit and hope to awaken the sleeping Jew inside me. Instead, she had the hots for her new rabbi and wanted me to meet him.
He was way hot. His wife, too. And that was the end of Julie and The Rabbi. However, I felt right at home. For the next few years, I studied and learned about this ancient yet modern religion. So many things felt like a good fit. For example, Israel means "to struggle" with God.
Score!
I also learned the major difference between Jews and Christians has nothing to do with Jesus. Oh, sure, some Jews are waiting for the Messiah. However, many of us take the Messianic Principle to mean that one person makes a difference and, with God's help, we can save ourselves.
SIDE NOTE: Don't even get me started on Messianic Jews. One cannot be both Christian and Jewish - no matter what Madonna says. Jews for Jesus are evangelical Christians out to save your soul. Run don't walk in the opposite direction. They're as bad as Scientologists. Ooops - intolerant moment. Sorry.
The main difference between Jews and Gentiles is a question of emphasis. Christians emphasize prayer while Jews stress the importance of study. Christians focus on belief; Jews - behavior. Simple as that. Or not. What do I know?
During my two-year conversion (no quickie dip in the lake and you're saved, thankyouverymuch), I also gained more of an appreciation for my Catholic heritage, the Pope, and all that Christianity has accomplished. They brought monotheism to the world, after all. Good job, peeps.
In the end, I picked a Hebrew name (Bruriah), got naked and jumped in the mikvah to come out an adopted daughter of Abraham and Sarah. Then I made my Jewish boyfriend-soon-to-be-husband put down his ham sandwich, pick up a yarmulke and get with the program. While I feel at home among Conservative, Reform, and Orthodox Jews, we picked a Reform Congregation and have been davening ever since.
I realize, for many, I am now your token Jew. So feel free to ask more questions as if I really know what I'm talking about.
15 Comments:
I count an encounter with Messianic Jews as one of the many reasons why I am an Atheist.
The way they acted was a lot like a cult. As a 16 year old I could see through what they were saying right to the contradictions. Ultimatly because of inconsistencies with each faith I looked into, I chose the only one that made sense, Atheism.
A lot of people think of Atheists as rebellous teenagers who just don't know what to believe, as if I am going through some sort of phase. On the contrary, Atheism is not the beginning of my spiritual journey, it is the end.
I like your post, many people are afraid to dicuss religion and while I don't believe in anyone's gods I LOVE to talk about it and how it affects people's lives, at least from a sociological viewpoint.
Religion is a great topic if you remember that your beliefs make sense to you and others are entitled to their own beliefs - however wrong they are.
That explains why I get along so well with the Amish.
;-)
Before we get started - I'm not arguing, just contributing. I don't do this very often, if ever, but for some reason I felt compelled to comment on this subject.
You said,
"The main difference between Jews and Gentiles is a question of emphasis. Christians emphasize prayer while Jews stress the importance of study. Christians focus on belief; Jews - behavior. Simple as that. Or not. What do I know?"
While I can't speak for Jews (or Athiest or Catholics), I'm pretty sure the emphasis for Protestant Christians is not prayer or belief, it's a relationship. At least it is for me and those that I know. Belief and prayer, although important, are simply steps and methods by which one comes to know God, and his son Jesus Christ.
Many people and faiths believe in God, nearly all of them pray. Those functions do not set the religions apart.
What I know of teh various religions goes like this -
Jews - awaiting salvation, Christ not the Messiah
Catholics - receive salvation through repentence, Christ is important, but not necessarily the Messiah
Mormons - I have heard lots of different things, which includes the abililty to become God-like and receive praise and worship from your own followers in your own universe. Christ was a prophet who spread the word to unknown lands, not the Messiah.
Islam - salvation only through submission to Allah, Christ was a prophet only
Buhdism - salvation is attainable through meditation and prayer. Christ was like Buddha, enlightened.
Protestant Christianity - salvation attainable only through acceptance of Jesus Christ, son of God and son of man, risen from the dead and living today, as your personal Lord and Savior
It is through this understanding that Protestants believe knowing Him and having a relationship with Him is not only possible, but sought out by Him, and it is through grace, that Jesus already paid the price for the sin of man, that one need only to accept Him - and thereby accept salvation - to be saved.
The realtionship with Christ, our saviour, is the emphasis of a protestant Christians life.
Any comments?
Several -
Protestants set themselves apart from Catholics in many ways, but both Catholics and Protestants believe that Jesus was the Son of God and the Messiah. (I'm not sure where you heard otherwise, but it's wrong wrong wrong.) This "belief" is what makes them Christians and the primary way of communicating with Christ is "prayer". (Although Catholics, alone among Christian denominations, emphasizes that good deeds is a part of the process. Not just belief.)
I should add that most religions include prayer, study, belief and behavior - with varying levels of importance. It is that "importance" that sets them apart from each other.
I'd never sum up Jews as awaiting salvation and Christ is not the Messiah. I'd sum them up by saying that Jews...well...I guess I couldn't sum them up any better than Hillel, who summed up the most important lesson in Judaism: "What is unfavorable to you, do not do to others. The rest is commentary. Now go and study."
Thanks for the personal insight. I got a laugh out of your "intolerant moment." And had a different ending to the sentence, "The main difference between Jews and Gentiles is a question of emphasis."
Oh, and a wonderful choice you made for your Hebrew name, even if you are a "token Jew."
Well, Kate, it's just what I have come to understand.
I found this (http://www.allaboutreligion.org/religion-comparison.htm)and I think it sums up what I am saying better than I can -
Most importantly, our daily walk with Christ must be rooted in a relationship of faith and love for our Lord...The church we attend each week is somewhat insignificant compared to how we devote ourselves to God with each moment in our life...
Christianity is a relationship with God through the power and grace of His Son, Jesus Christ. It is trusting in Jesus and what He did on the cross for you (1 Corinthians 15:1-4), not on what you can do for yourself (Ephesians 2:8-9). Christianity is not about religious traditions, ornate buildings, flamboyant preachers, rules, rituals or robes. Christianity is about truly receiving Jesus Christ as your Savior and Lord.
I don't believe Catholics do that. I am somewhat certain Jews do not.
Walk into ten different Protestant churches and you'll get ten different ideas of what Christianity is. Once you get past the central tenet of Christ as savior, anything goes. Trust me - I'm the guy that walked into ten different Protestant churches.
My wife and I attend our current church because - 1. It's her family's church and her mother likes us there; and 2) its emphasis is on study. I occasionally question the priority in study, but it sure beats churches that preach about giving every week.
I dare say Jesus as Messiah really is the key difference. I can guarantee you that there aren't many Protestant churches teaching the Messianic Principle you described.
If there is any emphasis that separates the two it's the emphasis on evangelicalism. I for one feel absolutely no calling or aptitude to convert anyone, and I am quite certain God doesn't want someone like me proselytizing. For that most Christians would brand me lazy, disobedient, whatever. I'm mostly just concerned with living my own life - if someone sees something in me they like and wants to know more, then we'll talk.
Hey, maybe I'm more Jewish than I think.
Okay, C, I think that sums up your beliefs quite nicely. I just think afterwards you should refrain from speaking for how Catholics receive Jesus. They believe they do - and you believe you do. And I think you're both right.
You're correct about us Jews, though. We're so going to hell.
Oh wait a minute, we don't believe in hell. Damn...
Joel - I still think the emphasis placed on belief and prayer is what really separates Christians from Jews. It was this idea that belief alone will save you that caused Christians to break away from Judaism to begin with - no more following kosher laws, observing the traditional Sabbath, etc.
Don't get me wrong - there are many other differences between Jews and Gentiles, too - the Messiah issue just being one. What about the whole "Jewish women are better in bed" thing? You see my point...
Let's focus on what we all have in common. Like guilt. And good food.
I'm a healer at heart.
What about the wiccans? No love for the wiccans?
(just kidding)
I think it's cool that you found your religion of choice & thanks for sharing the story. :-)
As for Hare Krishna... I don't know much about the religion, but the food is *wonderful* (yet another thing I miss about Los Angeles).
yes, guilt. we do have that.
On a lighter note, I was quite disappointed when looking at the picture of "jumped in the mikyah." I was sure it would be a picture of you...........
Facinating topic, but you should know that only Mormons go to heaven.
Don't you guys watch South Park?
Geez!!
Long story but I had a best friend who was Jewish, the only Jewish person in our sm. town HS. I befriended her when everyone picked on her using the JAP stereotypes and taunting with some nasty comments made on the part of people who's parents still taught them about how Jewish people killed Jesus.
I was fascinated with their cosmopolitanism -- they were originally from NYC -- and fell in love with all things Jewish. Every paper I had to write, I angled in a way to write about the religion and history.
Years later, people would ask my name in places where I met people a little more worldy and they would ask, are you Jewish.
I'd answer no and maybe tell them the story of my friend, etc.
Years later, my step-mother started doing genealogy to learn my father dad was Jewish. In this extremely small town where they had lived, he decided to hide that fact since he married a Christian.
Doesn't make me Jewish, of course, but I'd certainly have no qualms about converting either.
@ joel
That is totally fascinating! As much as I come of as a cranky atheist, I love studying religion and the practices embraced by communities of faith. Like Robert Bellah in Habits of the HEart, I really think communities of faith are an important part of people's lives and there have been some magnificent, socially positive things those communities have done for social progress: the Revolutionary War, The Abolition Movement, and the Civil Rights movement to name just a few.
Post a Comment
<< Home