Sunday, April 22, 2007

The Tampa Tribune Thinks Teachers Are Lazy

Reading the paper this weekend did not help to cure whatever stomach virus made its way into my system. (Or, as Oldest put it when answering the phone, "Mommy can't talk right now. She has the poops.")

Of course I'm talking about the latest attack on educators. This time in the editorial pages of the Trib.

Here is my response:

Dear Editor:

Your recent editorial attacking teachers won't help the public understand what is at stake in our high schools next year. You spent too little space outlining our superintendent's inadequate communication skills and too much time imploring teachers to play along.

Parents left out of redistricting discussions last year, teachers left out of scheduling decisions this year. Tell me: What is the best way to handle such a display of totalitarian leadership and the inevitable fall-out that occurs?

Instead of stressing the benefits of teachers and administrators working together, you continue to try pitting teacher against teacher, once again comparing high
school teachers to elementary school teachers. Divide and conquer will not work
in this situation. Most teachers are disappointed and frustrated with leadership
that devalues all of us. Repeating Elia's talking points, suggesting a raise
most of us aren't banking on, only makes your views less legitimate.

Teachers are not calling on co-workers to do the bare minimum. We aren't
threatening when we speak the truth about our ever-growing list of duties and
responsibilities at odds with enough hours in the day. We aren't whining when we
point out the difficulties resulting from a lack of quality leadership that
undermines our very existence and a community that misunderstands our roles.
Your editorial, with half-truths and faulty comparisons, does nothing to improve
the situation.

And you suggest we respond with silence. You believe we should play along. What kind of lesson would that teach our kids?

Our students are watching a superintendent who does her own thing no matter who is harmed. They are watching a school board give in to her every whim. They are
also watching their teachers come together to speak out against bad policies that
will negatively affect everyone. They are watching us speak up for our schools,
our jobs, our passion. Students are watching us speak up for them.

Haven't you heard? Those who can, teach. We can and we will fight for
what's right. Our students deserve nothing less.
There. My stomach feels much better.

5 Comments:

At 4/23/2007, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Welcome to a bureaucracy that should have never become a bureaucracy; education. Another fine example of what happens when you have too many chiefs and not enough Indians. Teachers joined their chosen occupation with both eyes opens, so enjoy your new work schedule and assignments. And don't forget the taxpayers who are paying your livelihood expect better results, that's why you have smaller classes so you have show a little more personal attention that you could before. Let's see if you're mature enough to handle it without complaining.

- Real World

 
At 4/23/2007, Anonymous Anonymous said...

My little brain is struggling to follow your line of reasoning. You start out bemoaning bureaucracy that is education, saying it should not be. Then you make the quantum leap to claim there are too many chiefs and not enough Indians. Next, you add something about teachers joined their occupations with both eyes opens [sic]. Finally, you beseech teachers to not "[f]orget the taxpayers who are paying for your livelihood expect better results [sic]..."

Apparently, you are trying to clear things up by closing with, "[t]that's why you have smaller classes so you have show [sic] a little more personal attention that you could before [sic].

Wow, normally I would respond to something like this with my official red correction pen, in which case the above little gem would be dripping with red. I guess you are trying to say you disagree with teachers who speak out and exercise the first amendment right that we teach to our students. Further, you seem to be using your taxpayer status to call teachers to task by demanding they give students a quality education.

I hope that helps. By the way, how many times did you skip when your English teachers were instructing the class on proper writing skills? You see, they tried to tell you that one day you would need those skills and that others would judge you on how well you used them.

- Real Syntax

 
At 4/23/2007, Anonymous Anonymous said...

>> I guess you are trying to say you disagree with teachers who speak out and exercise the first amendment right that we teach to our students. Further, you seem to be using your taxpayer status to call teachers to task by demanding they give students a quality education.<<

You guessed wrong, son.

>>I hope that helps. By the way, how many times did you skip when your English teachers were instructing the class on proper writing skills? You see, they tried to tell you that one day you would need those skills and that others would judge you on how well you used them.<<

Should the world ever need another grammar and spelling nazi, we'll be sure to let them know where to find you.

 
At 4/23/2007, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You neglected to capitalize Nazi. One capitalizes proper names.

 
At 4/23/2007, Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you'll say "Bush is Hitler" your day will be complete.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home